The 5-star ratings system for Medicare Advantage plans, a blueprint for the future government ratings on Obamacare health plans, is supplied to Medicare recipients to encourage more informed plan enrollments and, by implication, reduce the need to switch plans. The overall rating reflects treatment, preventive care, and customer satisfaction collected on the Medicare Advantage plan. Ideally, higher rated plans should have higher retention rates for plan enrollees. Recent research indicates that the star ratings of the plans are starting to move market share toward higher rated plans.1 The ratings system is well established, but critics have expressed concern that the data underlying the system has time lags.2
HealthPocket examined 448 Medicare Advantage plan contracts to determine how closely the star ratings are correlated to the member attrition rate, i.e. the voluntary cessation of enrollment in the Medicare Advantage plan by plan members. Inasmuch as CMS ratings at the contract level apply to all Medicare Advantage plans within each contract, the examination’s plan reach was in excess of 35,000 plans offered on a countywide basis throughout the United States.
Probably the greatest measure of customer dissatisfaction is the rate at which people voluntarily vote with their feet by disenrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan. The government publishes this data with a time lag, but even that data (from 2011) correlates to the star ratings for 2013 Medicare plans (established in the fall of 2012.)
As shown on the chart below the average Medicare Advantage attrition rate starts at a high level of 22 and 17 percent of all plan members discontinuing enrollment annually for 2 and 2.5 star plans. Plans with ratings in the range of 2 to 2.5 stars are the lowest rated Medicare Advantage plans. Plans that stay at this level for more than three years in a row are at risk of losing their ability to sell new Medicare Advantage plans. 5 star plans, in comparison, have an attrition rate of only 2 percent of members annually discontinuing enrollment in the Medicare Advantage plans.
The attrition results show that consumers are capable of measuring value they perceive in a plan. One aspect that may be particularly important to all health plan consumers is the extent to which voluntary attrition alerts other consumers to issues with managing significant health challenges.
Recently published research3 shows that changes in Medicare Advantage risk adjustment rules and open enrollment restrictions have caused the program to enroll a more balanced risk pool over time. This means that Medicare Advantage enrollees are generally no sicker or healthier than the overall Medicare population. However, the report indicated that those who disenroll from Medicare Advantage plans tend to have more health challenges than the general Medicare population. Medicare Advantage plans can provide coverage at a lower cost for many beneficiaries than Traditional Medicare combined with a wrap around supplemental plan and a prescription drug plan. However, it is crucial that the plan serve the enrollee well when they face significant health challenges.
Disenrollment data can also give early warnings about the adequacy of the plans’ physician and hospital networks as well as the accuracy of the sales and education process leading up to an enrollment. One report on anecdotal opinions on reasons for disenrollment from the Medicare Advantage program placed a low emphasis on premium increases.4 For 2013, 87 percent of beneficiaries will have access to a Medicare Advantage with prescription drug plan for no premium.5
When exploring the statistical relationship between attrition rates to Medicare plans overall star ratings, HealthPocket did establish a moderate correlation.6 However, when HealthPocket examined the statistical relationship between attrition rates and complaint rates for Medicare Advantage plans, a much stronger correlation was established. Complaints rate values represent complaint levels per thousand Medicare Advantage enrollees so a rate of 2 means that, on average, 2 members per thousand made complaints regarding the Medicare Advantage plan.
The below table illustrates the complaint and attrition rates aggregated within star rating categories.
HealthPocket’s research found a strong relationship between complaint rates and attrition rates. The variables rose and fell together. If complaints were high, so was attrition. Likewise. Low complaints were accompanied by low attrition.
Voluntary attrition and consumer complaint tracking are two meaningful ways of evaluating health plan quality. These factors have the additional benefits of being objectively measured, applied evenly throughout the industry and available on a near real time basis. The Medicare consumer market would have improved quality metrics if the government were to require or facilitate more rapid release of enrollee complaint and disenrollment data. It would constitute a rapid feedback system that would inform someone during the health plan review and selection process. The feedback loop will be an invaluable guide to emerging problems within health plans.
The Affordable Care Act ("ACA" also referred to as "Obamacare") is about to transform the individual and small business health insurance marketplace. A combination of guaranteed issue, subsidies and individual mandates will drive purchasers to insurance exchanges throughout the country. Health plans will have to provide coverage for categories of "essential health benefits" and offer policies in designated metal tiers that equate to the actuarial value of the insurance benefits. All these requirements will make health plans look more similar to one another and allow a clearer comparison based on premiums and out-of-pocket costs. It will take some time for government star ratings on Obamacare health plans, analogous to Medicare, to permeate the individual health plan market. Data on consumer behavior, such as complaints and disenrollment, will serve as a strong indicator of quality and need to be made available by the government to the public as rapidly as possible. Since people will need guidance early and frequently, the release of relevant consumer data will serve a crucial support role.
Given HealthPocket’s findings, data on available health plan complaint rates and attrition rates will be incorporated into Plan Details pages for plans on the market in 2014.
Data on attrition, complaints and star ratings were taken from 2013 CMS Medicare Part C Performance Data tabulations.7 The data was based on contract numbers, which can represent multiple plans. Medicare Advantage contract plans that were either too new or had insufficient data to be rated were eliminated from this review. The remaining plans were not adjusted for market share.
All analysis assumes the accuracy of the underlying government data. While every effort was made towards a representative collection of plans, HealthPocket makes no representation that every plan within the Medicare Advantage market was included in this study. Percentages are rounded according to standard industry practices.
Steve Zaleznick, Executive Director for Consumer Strategy and Development at HealthPocket.com, completed this survey analysis. Correspondence regarding this study can be directed to Mr. Zaleznick at email@example.com. Feedback and questions are welcome but, given the volume of email, personal responses may not be feasible.Google+
1 See Journal of American Medical Association: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1557733
2 See Kaiser Health News Network story about second guessing the star rating system: http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/stories/2012/may/21/medicare-star-ratings-quality.aspx
6 There was significant variation of attrition within each star rating category, though the averages followed star ratings closely.
HealthPocket is a free information source designed to help consumers find medical coverage. Whether you are looking for Medicare, Medicaid or an individual health insurance plan, we will help you find the right healthcare option and save on your out of pocket healthcare costs. We receive our data from government, non-profit and private sources, and you should confirm key provisions of your coverage with your selected health plan. If you select a plan presented on our site, you will be directed (via a click or a call) to one of our partners who can help you with your application. Our website is not a health insurance agency and not affiliated with and does not represent or endorse any health plan.